Important Notice: Any submissions made via this website does not constitute a binding agreement to your policy coverages. Changes to policies are not effective or binding until you, or any party involved, receive official notice from either your insurance agent or your insurance company. If you have any questions, please feel free to contact us.

Welcome to Pletcher Insurance

Dave Pletcher in front of Pletcher InsurancePletcher Insurance, Inc began in 1981 when Dave Pletcher bought the James L Hartman CLU & Associates Agency in Elkhart, Indiana. Dave began his Insurance career in 1970 when he secured his Property Casualty Agent’s license. Prior to buying the Agency, Dave worked for two other Insurance Agency’s.

                         Dave Pletcher

We have a wide range of insurance to offer from Automotive, Life, Health/Disability and Home Insurance.

"I love Pletcher Insurance. They have made my life easier with the great service and staff. They provide each and every time"

John S.

Sit back and enjoy life - let us take care of your insurance needs

Whether you need coverage for your home, car, business, or loved ones, you know you are in good hands with Pletcher Insurance. With four decades experience in the insurance industry, Dave knows how to get you the best coverage for the best deal. And the best part is that you can enjoy life without having to worry about the unexpected; Dave will always take care of you.

Would you like to learn more? Get a FREE quote from Pletcher Insurance using the form at the top of this page. We will prove that we are the best choice for your insurance needs.

Pletcher Insurance opened it’s current North Webster office in 2000, while keeping the Elkhart location, which was closed in 2001.